User Login    
 + Register
PDQ Cleaning
News : Lawyers: Missouri Moving Too Quickly On Executions
Posted by Randy on 2014/1/31 4:20:00 (693 reads) News by the same author

ST. LOUIS (AP) -- By the time the U.S. Supreme Court refused a last-minute request to stay the execution of Herbert Smulls, the Missouri inmate was already dead.
Click to see original Image in a new window

His attorneys said Thursday that it was the third straight case in which Missouri has moved ahead with an execution while the case was still in court.

While Missouri says it's perfectly legal to carry out executions before all appeals are exhausted, legal experts say the practice is rare. And the concerns from defense attorneys come as the death penalty in general is getting increased scrutiny amid separate questions about the drugs states are using to execute inmates.

Smulls, 56, was put to death late Wednesday after a protracted legal battle that lasted more than two decades, a legal fight that extended to his final day of life. Smulls was scheduled to die at 12:01 a.m. Wednesday, but various appeals pushed the case deep into the evening.

Attorneys for Smulls made one final push just before 10 p.m. for a stay from the U.S. Supreme Court, which had already ruled on other appeals that the execution could proceed. Timing was becoming a factor because the death warrant expired at 11:59 p.m. A new execution date would be required if Smulls was still alive at midnight.

He wasn't. The execution began at 10:11 p.m., and Smulls was pronounced dead at 10:20 p.m.

Joseph Luby, an attorney for Smulls, said he received an email at 10:30 p.m. from the Supreme Court, saying the stay application was denied at 10:24 p.m. - four minutes after Smulls was pronounced dead.

"It's just troubling and fundamentally lawless," Luby said.

Missouri Attorney General Chris Koster, in an emailed statement, said the state did nothing wrong.

"The United States Supreme Court has ruled that pending litigation is not sufficient to stop an execution," Koster wrote. "The legal mechanism for a federal court to stop an execution is a court-ordered stay."

Koster wrote that the state "directly asked the United States Supreme Court if the execution of Herbert Smulls should be stayed; for the third time that day, the Court said no. No stay of execution was in effect at the time of execution."

Missouri has executed three convicted killers in the past three months. Luby said that in all three cases, appeals were still pending.

One of the people executed was Allen Nicklasson. A three-judge panel of the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals had refused to grant a stay, but the full appeals court had not yet heard the case, Circuit Judge Kermit Bye wrote in a dissenting opinion days after that execution.

"In my near fourteen years on the bench, this is the first time I can recall this happening," the judge wrote.

Columbia Law School professor Jim Liebman said it is unusual, but not unheard of, for an execution to proceed with an appeal still pending. He agreed that corrections officials could reach the point of believing that enough is enough.

"You wouldn't be surprised if the state felt that way, maybe with justification, but the procedure is to have a court say that, not for the state to say that," Liebman said.

Texas, the nation's most active death penalty state, generally waits until all appeals are exhausted before carrying out executions.

In a few cases, the U.S. Supreme Court has put a halt to the stream of appeals by issuing an order that it would no longer accept petitions in a case, Liebman said. The court issued no such halt in Smulls' case.

"What that does is sort of put a legal end to the matter," Liebman said.

Attorneys for Smulls filed several appeals in the weeks and days leading up to the execution, and on the final day.

Many centered on concerns about the way Missouri obtains its execution drug from an unnamed compounding pharmacy. At least two recent executions have raised concerns about the effectiveness of drugs used in executions, putting increased scrutiny on how states carry out the death penalty. Two weeks ago, Ohio inmate Dennis McGuire took 26 minutes to die by injection, gasping repeatedly as he lay on a gurney with his mouth opening and closing. And on Jan. 9, Oklahoma inmate Michael Lee Wilson's final words were, "I feel my whole body burning."

Some of the other appeals centered on that fact that Smulls, who was black, was convicted by an all-white jury.

Florence Honickman called all the appeals a "travesty." She has permanent injuries after being shot by Smulls in the 1991 jewelry store robbery in suburban St. Louis that killed her husband, Stephen.

Honickman and her two adult children spent most of Tuesday and Wednesday at the prison in Bonne Terre, Mo., waiting through the late appeals until finally witnessing Smulls' death.

"I believe it is cruel and unacceptable both to the criminal about to be executed and to the victims' family that after endless appeals, 20-plus years on death row and after the execution date has been set, the criminal is given hope of a stay based on absurd technical and procedural matters," Florence Honickman said.

Printer Friendly Page Send this Story to a Friend Create a PDF from the article


Other articles
2015/6/29 7:40:02 - Rotary To Sponsor Exchange Student
2015/6/29 7:23:50 - Sullivan County Crowns Fair Queen
2015/6/29 6:36:20 - Fire Damages Trenton Residence
2015/6/29 6:32:09 - Saturday Accident At 13th And Cedar In Trenton Involves Gallatin And Trenton Residents
2015/6/29 4:51:25 - As Many As 16 Inured By Lightning Strike; Dog Killed
2015/6/29 4:39:47 - Air Show Continued After Tragedy
2015/6/29 4:35:18 - Missouri Trooper Shoots Suspect After I-70, U.S. 54 Pursuit
2015/6/29 4:20:00 - USDA Proposes Healthier Food For Child, Adult Day Cares
2015/6/29 4:15:22 - St. Louis' Minimum Wage Hike May Be Dead After Aldermanic Surprise
2015/6/29 4:09:35 - Man Convicted Of Sodomy With Child Commits Suicide
2015/6/29 4:00:14 - Good Samaritan Allows Woman To Hear Her Husband"s Voice Before He Dies
2015/6/29 4:00:00 - Poplar Bluff Granted Order Of Protection Against Sheriff's Department
2015/6/26 6:32:50 - 4 Injured When Vehicles Collide At Utica Intersection
2015/6/26 5:27:31 - Missouri State Fair Competition Deadline Approaching
2015/6/26 4:36:34 - National Guard Truck Crashes Into Overpass
2015/6/26 4:32:27 - Former Moberly School Bus Driver Pleads Guilty To Sex Crimes
2015/6/26 4:25:47 - Nitrogen Timing Critical In Wet Years
2015/6/26 4:17:06 - Grandmother Charged In Murder For Hire Plot Of Former Son-In-Law
2015/6/26 4:11:09 - North Central Missouri Fair Expands For 2015 Run
2015/6/25 8:55:07 - Chillicothe Firefighters Respond To Fire At Powerplant
2015/6/25 8:49:41 - Supreme Court Upholds Nationwide Health Care Law Subsidies
2015/6/25 7:55:31 - Stolen ATV Leads To Big Tow Fees For Victim
2015/6/25 7:51:56 - Missouri Woman Charged With Murder After Shoe Argument Turns Violent
2015/6/25 7:38:22 - Grundy County Circuit Court News
2015/6/25 7:30:00 - North Central Missouri Fair Seeks Entrants For Fair Queen Contest
2015/6/25 7:24:07 - Princeton Board Of Education Adopts Budget
2015/6/25 6:40:00 - Trenton Police Chief Tommy Wright To Attend Southern Police Institute
2015/6/25 6:40:00 - Grundy County Sheriff Arrests Trenton Resident On Multiple Drug Charges
2015/6/25 4:21:29 - Police: Two Women Died After Using Meth With Monett Man
2015/6/25 4:16:09 - Satan Worshippers Sue Missouri Governor, Attorney General Over Abortion Law



Bookmark this article at these sites

                   

Listen to KTTN-FM