User Login    
 + Register
News : Teen Killer Wants To Undo Guilty Plea
Posted by Randy on 2014/1/30 4:30:05 (843 reads) News by the same author

JEFFERSON CITY, Mo. (AP) -- A Missouri teen who wrote that killing a young neighbor girl was an "ahmazing" thrill wants a judge to overturn a guilty plea that she now says was made under the threat of a lifetime in prison.
Click to see original Image in a new window

Alyssa Bustamante was to appear in court Thursday for a hearing on whether to set aside her plea in the 2009 slaying of 9-year-old Elizabeth Olten in a rural community just west of Jefferson City. Bustamante was 15 at the time and wrote in her diary on the night of the killing that it was an "ahmazing" and "pretty enjoyable" experience.

Bustamante was charged as an adult with first-degree murder, which carries a mandatory prison sentence of life without the possibility of parole. Shortly before she was to go to trial, Bustamante pleaded guilty in January 2012 to a reduced charge of second-degree murder and was sentenced to life with a chance of parole.

She also pleaded guilty to armed criminal action for using a knife in the slaying and received an additional 30-year sentence to run at the conclusion of her life sentence.

Five months after Bustamante pleaded guilty, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in a separate case that juveniles cannot face automatic life sentences without the possibility of parole.

Bustamante's new attorney is citing that ruling as a reason to undo her guilty plea.

"The threat of (life without parole) as a mandatory sentence was allowed to intimidate Alyssa into accepting a guilty plea she would not have otherwise accepted," Columbia attorney Gary Brotherton wrote in documents filed with the Cole County Circuit Court.

Brotherton declined an interview in advance of Bustamante's hearing.

Prosecutor Mark Richardson said Bustamante's claims "do not have any merit" and her original sentence should stand.

"Generally, they're very big long shots to try to prove that somehow some bad advice caused a person to plead guilty when they otherwise wouldn't have," Richardson said in an interview.

Bustamante's attorney claims her due process rights were violated because the original first-degree murder charge would have resulted in an unconstitutionally cruel and unusual punishment. He contends in court documents that her actual sentence is similarly unconstitutional because "it does not provide her with any realistic opportunity for release."

At the time of her sentencing, the Missouri Department of Corrections said Bustamante would have to serve 35 years and five months before she is eligible for parole. She's currently listed as a prisoner at an eastern Missouri facility.

Brotherton's court filing also argues that Bustamante's original attorneys provided ineffective advice. Among other things, it says they pressured her during a more than half hour jailhouse visit to make a quick decision to plead guilty to second-degree murder without explaining that a pending Supreme Court case could have affected her range of punishment.

Evidence presented during Bustamante's 2012 sentencing hearing revealed she had dug a shallow grave in the woods several days before the slaying and used her younger sister to lure Elizabeth with an invitation to play. Bustamante said she had a surprise for Elizabeth in the forest but instead strangled her, sliced her throat and stabbed her. After hundreds of volunteers searched for two days, Bustamante led authorities to Elizabeth's body, buried in a wooded area about a half-mile from Bustamante's house.

Printer Friendly Page Send this Story to a Friend Create a PDF from the article

Other articles
2015/10/8 7:44:49 - Spickard Men Travel To Washington, DC On Heartland Honor Flight
2015/10/8 7:37:59 - NRCS Sets November 20 Deadline For Missouri Farmers And Ranchers To Apply For Assistance
2015/10/8 7:29:50 - Missouri High Schools Challenged To Drive Safe: Buckle Up Safe Driving Campaign Educates To Save Teen Lives
2015/10/8 6:50:18 - 4-H'er With Cerebral Palsy Heads To American Royal
2015/10/8 6:00:52 - Grundy County Sheriff Reports Two In Custody
2015/10/8 4:24:23 - Grundy County United Way Kicks Off Fund Drive This Saturday
2015/10/8 4:20:00 - MU Students Protest Thomas Jefferson Statue, Call For Its Removal
2015/10/8 4:08:39 - AG Koster Alerts Customers To T-Mobile, Experian Data Breach
2015/10/8 4:05:00 - Moberly Trailer Factory Plans Layoffs
2015/10/8 4:00:52 - Tractor-Trailer Goes Airborne In I-35 Accident
2015/10/8 3:58:26 - Sexual Assault Reported On MWSU Campus
2015/10/8 3:52:35 - Dangerous Building In Macon Coming Down
2015/10/7 11:56:16 - Food Prices Continue To Rise For Missourians
2015/10/7 11:34:43 - SUV Hits Farm Vehicle In Gentry County
2015/10/7 11:31:22 - Clinton County Accident Injures Maysville Man
2015/10/7 11:30:00 - Polo Bank Robber Receives Prison Sentence
2015/10/7 6:47:44 - Police Begin Death Investigation After Body Found In Hannibal Home
2015/10/7 6:43:01 - Roughly 6000 Federal Inmates To Be Released
2015/10/7 6:30:00 - Chillicothe Fire Department / Red Cross / Wellness Committee Working To Reduce Deaths, Injuries Due To Fires
2015/10/7 6:25:15 - Missouri Department Of Conservation Expands Pheasant Hunting Statewide
2015/10/7 4:24:58 - Trouble Still Finds Franklin County Missouri Man Who Killed Two Intruders
2015/10/7 4:19:33 - Dog Shot During Dispute Between Neighbors
2015/10/7 4:14:25 - Man Jumps Off Bridge While Running From Police
2015/10/7 4:11:23 - Man Dies After Jumping From 3rd Floor Window In Handcuffs
2015/10/7 4:07:39 - MU Students Protest Inside Jesse Hall After Report Of Racism
2015/10/7 4:03:32 - Missouri Hospitals Seeing More Opioid Addiction
2015/10/7 3:52:55 - Expert Recommends Replacing Older Smoke Detectors
2015/10/7 3:50:00 - Atlanta Man Sentenced For Fraud Scheme That Used Homeless To Cash Counterfeit Checks
2015/10/6 16:32:42 - Penney High School's Cornelius Finishes 3rd At Sectionals, Advances To State
2015/10/6 15:42:23 - One Vehicle Accident Reported Near Livonia

Bookmark this article at these sites


Listen to KTTN-FM