User Login    
 + Register
PDQ Cleaning
News : Court Orders Release Of Church Abuse Records
Posted by Randy on 2014/1/10 4:25:20 (513 reads) News by the same author

The Archdiocese of St. Louis must release two decades worth of sexual abuse allegations against its priests, an appellate court ordered Thursday.

Click to see original Image in a new window

But no sooner had the Missouri Court of Appeals court issued its ruling than the archdiocese announced its intent to take the matter to the Missouri Supreme Court.

Meanwhile, the issue goes back to St. Louis Circuit Court Judge Robert Dierker, who has already rapped the archdiocese for missing two previous deadlines he set for releasing the material.

At issue are 234 complaints made against 115 priests. The records are sought as part of a 2011 suit filed on behalf a then-19-year-old woman, who said she was sexually abused from 1997-2001 by the since-defrocked Rev. Joseph Ross.

Many of the names and corresponding records fall under a protective order, for lawyers’ eyes only. But the release of the documents — unprecedented in St. Louis — could give rise to further legal claims.

“We’re very pleased with (the decision),” said Ken Chackes, an attorney for the woman publicly known only as Jane Doe. “It fully supported Judge Dierker’s decision, which we thought was fair and reasonable.”

Attorneys for the archdiocese sought the appellate court’s intervention Jan. 3, the day of Dierker’s latest deadline. In filings, they called his order “pure error and a clear abuse of discretion.” The appeals court then granted a temporary stay.

But in a brief order Thursday, Eastern District Appellate Judge Glenn Norton wrote that Dierker’s order “adequately addressed” privacy concerns voiced by the archdiocese, and found that the documents are relevant to the civil claim being made.

Norton’s order notes that the archdiocese should not be treated differently from any other litigant.

A spokeswoman for the archdiocese, Angie Shelton, responded with a statement saying, “We respect the trial court’s efforts to build mechanisms to address these challenging issues, but we continue to disagree that an unprecedented invasion of third parties’ lives is warranted.”

She added, “The fact that the appeal was initially granted shows how difficult this issue is for all involved, the parties and the courts.”

The plaintiff’s lawyers believe the documents will show the archdiocese had a pattern of ignoring problems within the church and knew of the risk in assigning Ross to St. Cronan’s Parish in the city’s Forest Park Southeast neighborhood.

He previously had been convicted of sexually abusing an 11-year-old boy at a University City parish and was sent away for treatment. He was then reassigned to St. Cronan’s, where he allegedly abused Doe from 1997 to 2001.

Attorneys for the archdiocese had argued that releasing the names of the accusers would “be harmful to them” based on “unrebutted evidence from expert medical professions.” They also voiced concern that the plaintiff’s lawyers, if given the names of victims, could cause emotional damage by stirring up traumatic memories.

Doe’s attorneys had asked for the names of all priests and lay employees accused of sexual abuse here in the past 40 years. Dierker initially limited the time frame to 20 years, then modified it to eliminate the requirement pertaining to nonclergy employees.

The archdiocese so far has only release a so-called “matrix” of the 234 complaints dating to 1986, which identifies accusers and the 115 accused by numbers only, without any other specifics, such as the priests’ assignments within the archdiocese.

Some employees were named on multiple complaints, including two who had 15.

Dierker’s order allows the archdiocese to withhold records pertaining to 40 of those complaints that the archdiocese deemed “unsubstantiated.” But Chackes said most of those relate to priests who will be named through other, substantiated claims.

The order also stresses that neither the plaintiff nor her attorney can directly contact those who filed the complaints. A court-appointed attorney will make the initial contact to see whether victims want to cooperate. The trial date is Feb. 24.

Dierker has awarded the plaintiff an early victory as far as compensatory damages, by issuing a partial judgment that determined the archdiocese did know of the risk in assigning Ross to St. Cronan’s.

He also fined the archdiocese for its delays.

“The dogged refusal of defendant Archdiocese to comply with the Court’s orders has inflicted unnecessary trouble and expense on plaintiff, manifestly interfered with trial preparation, and borders on if not actually amounting to contempt,” Dierker wrote. “The Court cannot condone such behavior.”

Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests, a victims’ advocacy group, said 115 is more than double the number of previously known alleged abusers in the archdiocese.

David Clohessy of St. Louis, SNAP’s director, said in a statement Thursday: “We are grateful that this brave young woman is persisting and that the appeals court says Catholic officials must follow the same rules as other defendants in child sex abuse cases.”

Printer Friendly Page Send this Story to a Friend Create a PDF from the article


Other articles
2015/7/2 8:58:03 - Wright Memorial Hospital Foundation Receives Grant From Union Pacific
2015/7/2 8:49:30 - Trenton Park Board Meets
2015/7/2 8:45:38 - Tri-County Board Of Education Approves Budget
2015/7/2 6:35:02 - Teen Receives Serious Injuries, Demolishes Vehicle In Accident Near Green City
2015/7/2 4:43:49 - Macon Officials Dedicate Solar Farm
2015/7/2 4:38:49 - Police: Missouri Man Kills Self During Standoff
2015/7/2 4:29:07 - Missouri Public Service Commission Rejects Plan For Multistate Wind Power
2015/7/2 4:12:53 - Police: Bomb Found In Car During Springfield Traffic Stop
2015/7/2 4:09:03 - New Law In Effect Allows Kansans To Carry Concealed Weapons Without Permit
2015/7/2 4:03:37 - School Charges Mother $77,000 For Access To Emails Involving Son
2015/7/1 7:36:28 - Chillicothe Man Injured When Pool Carries Him Out Of Pickup
2015/7/1 6:37:47 - Clerk Accused Of Shooting Teen Allegedly Over Theft Of Cookies
2015/7/1 6:31:57 - Boy Found Chained To Porch With Chicken Around Neck Speaks Out For First Time
2015/7/1 5:28:17 - Public School Application Asks If Child Was Born By C-Section
2015/7/1 4:45:45 - Mom Arrested After Boy 4, Left Tied On Leash To Bush
2015/7/1 4:36:46 - Death Of Boy Pushed In Swing For 3 Days Ruled Homicide
2015/7/1 4:30:00 - Former Circuit Clerk From Northeast Missouri Enters Plea
2015/7/1 4:24:53 - Teens Storm Georgia Wal-Mart In Wild Rampage Of Destruction
2015/6/30 6:31:13 - Mosaic To Offer Reduced Cost Sports Physicals
2015/6/30 4:47:08 - Son Arrested After Argument Over Spoiled Meat
2015/6/30 4:34:11 - Woman Gives Birth Alone On Back Road, Is Stranded With Newborn For Three Days
2015/6/30 4:21:04 - Man In Custody After Moberly Police Chase
2015/6/30 4:16:46 - Officer Crashes Into Home When Responding To What Turned Out As Prank Call
2015/6/30 4:10:10 - Missouri Man Sentenced To 6 Years In Synthetic Pot Case
2015/6/30 4:04:35 - Daycare Worker Arrested For Battery On 1-Year-Old
2015/6/29 7:40:02 - Rotary To Sponsor Exchange Student
2015/6/29 7:23:50 - Sullivan County Crowns Fair Queen
2015/6/29 6:36:20 - Fire Damages Trenton Residence
2015/6/29 6:32:09 - Saturday Accident At 13th And Cedar In Trenton Involves Gallatin And Trenton Residents
2015/6/29 4:51:25 - As Many As 16 Inured By Lightning Strike; Dog Killed



Bookmark this article at these sites

                   

Listen to KTTN-FM