User Login    
 + Register
News : Waste Corporation Of Missouri Files Suit Against City Of Trenton
Posted by Randy on 2013/12/9 10:20:00 (621 reads) News by the same author

Waste Corporation of Missouri has filed a suit in Division One of Grundy County Circuit Court asking for a restraining order, temporary injunction, and permanent injunction against the City of Trenton to prohibit the city from awarding the 2014 to 2018 residential sanitation collection and disposal contract to Rapid Removal.

Click to see original Image in a new window

The suit also asks for the City Council to be required to reconsider the contract using only factors specified in the City Code section called determining the lowest responsible bidder. Waste Corporation also asks that it be awarded other relief the court deems appropriate.

In addition, Waste Corporation is asking for a declaratory judgment declaring that the Trenton City Council violated a section of City Code by basing its decision to award the contract to Rapid Removal on factors not permitted in the section of City Code called determining the lowest responsible bidder.

The petition notes the Trenton City Council voted to award the contract to Rapid Removal, even though Waste Corporation of Missouri's bid was what Waste Corporation called significantly lower than Rapid Removal's bid.

The petition cites a section of Trenton City Code, titled determining the lowest responsible bidder. The petition says the section establishes a list of 7 exclusive factors the City of Trenton must take into account when determining who will receive a City contract that's been competitively bid. They include price and performance factors. The suit claims the decision to award the contract to Rapid Removal was based on considerations not included in the 7 factors.

Waste Corporation claims that based on public comments made by members of the City Council explaining their votes, the City selected Rapid Removal solely because it allegedly has a larger local presence in Trenton, notwithstanding the fact its bid was what the suit claimed to be significantly higher that Waste Corporation's bid. The suit said none of the factors of the City Code section authorize a decision based on such a factor.

Waste Corporation suit claims the City's awarding the contract to Rapid Removal was arbitrary, capricious, and illegal.

The suit says Waste Corporation of Missouri is a taxpayer within the City of Trenton, paying among other things, personal property taxes on containers used by its commercial customers within the City of Trenton.

Waste Corporation said it will suffer irreparable harm if an injunction is not granted, because once the 2014 to 2018 contract begins and is executed, Waste Corporation of Missouri would be excluded from providing waste disposal services to residents of Trenton.

The suit says preliminary and permanent injunctive relief in the case is in the public interest. It says the public has an interest in seeing contracts for public services are awarded to the lowest responsible or qualified bidder. It also says the public has an interest in seeing municipal governments follow their own city ordinances to protect the integrity of the bidding process and to reduce the risk of arbitrary, fraudulent, and biased decisions these ordinances are meant to prevent.

Trenton City Attorney, Tara Walker, told KTTN she could not comment at this time.

Those 7 factors include bid price; the ability of the bidder to provide the services required; whether the bidder can provide the services within the required time periods; the quality of performance on previous contracts or services with the city and/or references provided; previous and existing compliance by the bidder with laws and ordinances of the city; financial resources and ability of the bidder to provide the service; and the quality, availability, and adaptability of the supplies or services.

The Trenton City Council, on 5 to 1 vote on November 25th, approved a bid from Rapid Removal Disposal to provide residential trash collection service during the next 5 years.

Rapid Removal had the middle bid of 3 received. Waste Corporation was the low bidder. Its bid---for the entire 5 year period---- was $53.76 less per customer than Rapid Removal.

3 years ago, when a 3 year contract was awarded to Waste Corporation, Waste Corporation had highest bid among the 3 companies submitting quotes. Rapid Removal, which was new to this area, had the low bid 3 years ago. However, the City Council chose WCA because of public support for WCA to continue providing the service. Rapid removal's bid 3 years ago was more than $32 less per customer than the WCA quote for the 3 year period.

The City of Trenton does have a policy elsewhere in its code that promotes local purchases to the greatest extent practical. Its generally to be within 5 percent, but the City Council or a Board has the final authority in applying the local incentive.

Printer Friendly Page Send this Story to a Friend Create a PDF from the article


Other articles
2014/11/26 10:12:40 - Amaren Files Application To Raise Charge On Bills
2014/11/26 10:08:15 - NCMC Board Of Trustees Meeting Report
2014/11/26 9:53:35 - Gallatin Residents To See Increase In Water Bills
2014/11/26 9:50:52 - No Green Card For Lauren Gray: Dancer Leaves For London Saturday
2014/11/26 9:45:04 - Trenton Man Sentenced To Five Years In Prison
2014/11/26 9:42:24 - Missouri Taxpayers Sue Nixon For Common Core Tests
2014/11/26 6:49:29 - Trenton City Council Meeting Report
2014/11/26 4:18:15 - Google's Latest: A Spoon That Steadies Tremors
2014/11/26 4:12:02 - The Forgotten First President (Hint: It wasn't George Washington)
2014/11/26 4:05:51 - Neighbors React To Permit For Controversial Hog Farm
2014/11/26 3:59:19 - Police: Teens Steal From Cancer Patient
2014/11/26 3:55:10 - Salvation Army Revisiting Policy After Family Turned Away Due To Age Of Son
2014/11/25 7:36:07 - University City, Mo. Officer Shot In Chest, Woman Dies
2014/11/25 6:24:44 - Cameron Man Injured In Single Vehicle Accident: Accused Of DUI
2014/11/25 6:22:00 - Lighting Contest To Be Held In Mercer County
2014/11/25 6:20:00 - NCMC Softball Signs Platte County Recruit
2014/11/25 4:35:59 - Man Fighting For His Life After Being Run Over At McDonald's Drive-Thru
2014/11/25 4:23:44 - 17-Year Old Suspect Charged With Murdering His Grandmother Pleads Insanity
2014/11/25 4:20:11 - Missouri Lottery Will Advertise In Fortune Cookies
2014/11/25 4:17:38 - 17-Year Old Arrested: Robbed Shop With Airsoft Gun
2014/11/25 4:09:06 - Family Upset Officers Used Deadly Force Against Suicidal Teen
2014/11/25 4:00:00 - Police: Video Of Officer Shooting 12-Year Old Boy Is 'Clear'
2014/11/25 3:59:18 - With No Indictment, Chaos Fills Ferguson Streets
2014/11/24 17:20:58 - Princeton Boys Seeded #2 For Albany Tournament
2014/11/24 16:50:00 - Milan To Open 2014-2015 Basketball Season At Novinger Tournament
2014/11/24 12:00:25 - Trenton Boys Sweep Cameron Jamboree, Prepare For East Buchanan
2014/11/24 11:32:36 - KC Chiefs Add Receiving Depth, Signing Jason Avant
2014/11/24 11:21:24 - Gallatin Girls, Trenton Boys Earn #1 Seeds At Gallatin Tourney
2014/11/24 10:52:24 - Michaelis Notches Career High 17, Mizzou Falls To #14 California
2014/11/24 10:41:08 - Trenton Girls Open Season With Home Jamboree



Bookmark this article at these sites

                   

Listen to KTTN-FM